S’mores had barely left the animal shelter when his chance at a new home came to an abrupt end.
The dog had been staying at a shelter in the San Francisco Bay Area, waiting for someone to adopt him. When a family finally chose him, it seemed his time in the kennel was over.
He walked out of the building with the people who had agreed to take him home.
But just thirty minutes later, S’mores was back.
The reason given for his return was that he was “too big.”
Shelter staff were stunned. His size had been apparent when he was adopted, and nothing about him had changed during that brief time away.
For S’mores, what should have been the beginning of a new life had lasted only half an hour.
But when local rescuers heard what had happened, they decided his story couldn’t end with another long stay in a kennel.

Thirty minutes was all he got
There is usually a period of adjustment when a newly adopted dog enters a home.
The animal needs time to understand an unfamiliar environment, learn household routines, and become comfortable with new people.
For S’mores, that opportunity never really began.
Within thirty minutes of leaving the shelter, he was returned because his adopters considered him too large.
The explanation was difficult for the people who later became involved in his rescue to understand.
Sarah Meiches, cofounder and president of Mutt Luv Rescue, was among those who heard about the incident.
“We were completely flabbergasted with S’mores’ story,” she told The Dodo.
Meiches pointed out the obvious problem with the reason for his return: S’mores hadn’t suddenly become a larger dog.
His size and weight were the same when he came back as they had been when he left.
The brief adoption had given him no meaningful chance to settle into the household or demonstrate what kind of companion he could become.
And when he returned to the shelter, he appeared subdued.
The news was upsetting for the local rescue community, especially because the people hearing about him believed he deserved another opportunity.
They began looking for a way to get him into a home where he could adjust without being hurried.
A foster home opened its doors
Mutt Luv Rescue began coordinating a plan to help S’mores.
The first priority was finding someone who could temporarily welcome him into a home.
Within a few hours, a foster caregiver volunteered.
That gave the rescue team a place where S’mores could go, but they still needed help arranging his release and transportation.
Another organization, Not Your Average Rescue, joined the effort.
Together, the rescue groups coordinated a pickup and found someone who could transport S’mores to his foster home.
It took more than one person to make the arrangement work.
There was the foster volunteer willing to open her home, the rescue organizations handling the coordination, and the person helping with transportation.
Each played a part in giving S’mores another chance.
“Within a few hours, we had an amazing foster step up and offer to open her heart and home to help him,” Meiches explained.
Soon, S’mores was out of the shelter again.
This time, nobody was expecting him to understand everything about his new surroundings in thirty minutes.
He would have the opportunity to learn.

Learning how to live inside a home
Once S’mores arrived at his foster placement, his caregivers began noticing something unexpected.
He seemed unfamiliar with ordinary household life.
After watching him for several days, the foster family suspected that he might never have lived inside a house before.
That could help explain why a home environment wasn’t immediately familiar to him.
Dogs who haven’t experienced regular household routines may need time to learn which spaces are theirs, how to settle indoors, and what their caregivers expect.
S’mores was no exception.
But his foster family found him willing to learn.
With patient encouragement and consistent guidance, he began adjusting to his new surroundings.
The dog who had been returned after thirty minutes was now being given the time to become comfortable.
And as he settled in, his foster caregivers began discovering his personality.
He was curious about the world around him.
He enjoyed interacting with people.
And he seemed happiest when he could be involved in whatever his family was doing.
The more they got to know him, the harder it became to understand why his first adoption had ended so quickly.
The dog who wanted to be included in everything
S’mores turned out to be an affectionate, sociable dog with plenty of enthusiasm.
He enjoyed learning new skills and participating in training.
He loved getting outside for hikes and adventures with his foster family.
And when the day’s activities were finished, he was perfectly happy curling up for a cuddle.
Meiches described him as smart, playful, happy, and curious.
But one quality stood out more than the others.
S’mores wanted to be close to his people.
He didn’t seem particularly concerned about what they were doing.
Whether someone was working, cooking, exercising, or simply moving around the house, he wanted to be nearby.
Even brushing their teeth could become an activity he wanted to supervise.
And when it was time to relax on the couch, S’mores was delighted to join them.
He was the kind of dog who enjoyed being part of the household rather than spending his days apart from everyone.
For a family looking for an affectionate companion who wanted to share everyday life, that could be a wonderful quality.
It just required people who appreciated his energy and understood his size.

A big dog with an even bigger personality
S’mores wasn’t a perfectly trained dog when he entered foster care.
He could become overexcited, and he still had things to learn.
His foster family recognized that.
But they also saw how quickly he responded to guidance.
He enjoyed training sessions and appeared eager to understand what was expected of him.
Instead of treating his enthusiasm as a reason to give up, his caregivers worked with him.
Over time, he made progress.
His size hadn’t changed.
He was still the same large dog who had been returned to the shelter after half an hour.
But now his caregivers knew much more about him.
They knew he liked adventures.
They knew he enjoyed affection.
They knew he was curious, sociable, and eager to be included.
And they knew that, with consistent support, he was capable of becoming a comfortable household companion.
Those were qualities his first adopters had barely had time to discover.
What S’mores needed from his next family
The rescue team didn’t believe S’mores was the right dog for absolutely everyone.
His size and enthusiasm were real considerations.
A large, energetic dog needs appropriate space, regular exercise, training, and people prepared to manage his physical strength.
Those responsibilities shouldn’t be overlooked.
But they also didn’t mean S’mores was unsuitable for family life.
His foster experience showed that he could learn household routines and develop a strong bond with the people caring for him.
He simply needed a family whose expectations matched the dog he actually was.
“With a little support, he’s going to be the pawfect addition to the right family,” Meiches told The Dodo.
It was a hopeful assessment grounded in what his foster caregivers had observed.
S’mores wasn’t being described as an effortless pet who would never need training.
He was a lively, affectionate dog who responded well to patient guidance.
And the rescue wanted him to find people willing to continue that work.

More than thirty minutes
What stays with me about S’mores’ story is the enormous difference between his two experiences.
In the first, he was adopted and returned almost immediately.
Thirty minutes.
Not enough time for a dog to understand his new surroundings, let alone settle into unfamiliar routines.
His second opportunity looked very different.
A foster volunteer welcomed him into her home.
She gave him time.
She helped him learn.
And as the days passed, she discovered a dog who enjoyed training, loved outdoor adventures, and wanted to be involved in nearly everything his people did.
The same size that had ended his first adoption was still there.
But now someone was getting to know the personality that came with it.
S’mores hadn’t needed to become a different dog.
He needed people who understood what caring for him would involve.
And a little patience while he adjusted.
As of the original report published on March 30, 2024, S’mores was thriving in foster care and still looking for his permanent home.
The story did not confirm that he’d been adopted again.
But his circumstances had already improved considerably.
He was no longer waiting in a shelter kennel.
He had a foster caregiver who appreciated his affectionate nature, recognized his enthusiasm, and was helping him develop the skills he needed.
He had opportunities to explore, learn, and enjoy ordinary family activities.
And he was finally receiving something his first adoption hadn’t allowed.
Time.
S’mores was returned to a shelter just thirty minutes after being adopted because he was considered too big. But when rescuers arranged a foster home, they discovered an intelligent, affectionate dog who loved learning and being close to people.
His first adoption had barely begun before it ended.
His next chapter was still being written.
And the people who had come to know him believed that somewhere, there was a family who wouldn’t see his size as a reason to turn him away.
They would see S’mores.
A big, enthusiastic dog who wanted little more than to be part of someone’s life.
Source: Caitlin Jill Anders, The Dodo, March 30, 2024. Based on original reporting and statements from Sarah Meiches, cofounder and president of Mutt Luv Rescue, with rescue assistance from Not Your Average Rescue. S’mores’ adoption status reflects the information available when the article was published.
























Discussion about this post