The call was supposed to help a lost dog get home.
On May 19, 2024, a small white dog wandered into a neighbor’s yard in Sturgeon, Missouri.
His name was Teddy.
He weighed about 13 pounds. He was a Shih Tzu mix, deaf since he was very young and partially or completely blind by the time he was a few years old. His owner, Nicholas Hunter, had raised him from the time Teddy was about 12 weeks old. Teddy was roughly five years old when he died.
The neighbor did what many people would have done after finding a vulnerable dog with no owner in sight.
She gave Teddy water.
She tried to keep him safe.
Then she called for help locating the person who belonged to him.
In the small city of Sturgeon, police officers also handled animal-control responsibilities.
Officer Myron Woodson responded.
His body camera recorded what followed.
Within minutes, Teddy was dead.
Teddy Had Simply Wandered Away From Home
Teddy had escaped from his fenced yard and somehow reached a nearby property.
Because he could not see or hear normally, his movements could look unusual to someone unfamiliar with him.
Contemporary reporting described him using his nose to navigate the yard. The neighbor who found him said he drank from a bowl she provided and even licked her arm and leg during the approximately 45 minutes he was with her.
She did not describe an aggressive dog.
Quite the opposite.
Later, she said Teddy had posed no threat to her.
What Teddy needed was fairly simple.
Someone had to identify his owner.
Until then, he needed to be kept somewhere safe.
That was why the neighbor called authorities.
Officer Woodson Arrived With a Catch Pole
Woodson came equipped with gloves and a catch pole, sometimes called a snare pole.
Such equipment can be used to secure an animal while maintaining some distance.
But body-camera footage showed that Woodson had difficulty catching Teddy.
The small dog repeatedly moved away from him.
According to the federal complaint later filed by Hunter, Teddy did not bark, growl, charge, or move toward the officer aggressively.
He kept trying to move away.
That distinction became central to everything that followed.
This was not a case in which an officer confronted a large dog rushing toward someone.
Teddy weighed approximately 13 pounds.
He was deaf.
He was blind.
And the available video became the most important record of what happened in that yard.
The Body Camera Captured Three Minutes and Six Seconds
The encounter was brief.
Local reporting that later reviewed the footage calculated that three minutes and six seconds passed between the point when Woodson first approached Teddy closely and the first gunshot.
During that period, the officer tried several times to use the catch pole.
The attempts failed.
At one point, Woodson could be heard considering another option.
He mentioned throwing a towel or blanket over Teddy.
He did not do it.
Instead, he drew his firearm.
Then he shot Teddy at close range.
He fired a second time.
The lost dog the neighbor had hoped to reunite with his family never made it home.
Teddy’s Disabilities Help Explain the Behavior the City Later Questioned
After the shooting drew public attention, Sturgeon initially defended Woodson’s actions.
A city statement said the dog had been “behaving strangely and displaying signs of possible injuries” and that the behavior had been perceived as possibly indicating rabies.
That explanation became controversial almost immediately.
Hunter said Teddy was current on his vaccinations, including rabies protection.
He also explained why Teddy sometimes held his head at an unusual angle or walked differently.
The dog was blind and deaf and had a neurological condition.
His movements were not evidence that he was attacking anyone.
They were part of how Teddy navigated the world.
The neighbor who had called authorities also rejected the idea that Teddy had acted dangerously.
She later submitted a formal complaint.
The Person Who Called for Help Had Already Been Safely Near Teddy
That detail made the shooting especially difficult for many residents to understand.
Before police arrived, Teddy had spent substantial time in the neighbor’s yard.
She had been close enough to give him water.
He had licked her.
Nothing about that interaction required lethal force.
Her purpose in calling was to find out where he belonged.
She was not reporting that she was being attacked.
She was trying to help a lost animal.
Then the person she had called for assistance arrived.
A few minutes later, Teddy was dead.
Hunter learned that his dog would not be coming home.
Hunter Had Owned Teddy Since He Was a Puppy
The federal lawsuit later stated that Hunter had cared for Teddy for approximately five years, beginning when the dog was about 12 weeks old.
That history matters because legal cases involving the destruction of a companion animal often use language such as “property” or “seizure.”
Those terms have specific constitutional meanings.
They do not describe what losing a dog feels like inside a household.
Teddy was the small dog who lived with Hunter.
Contemporary reporting described him as playful and fond of stealing socks.
He had disabilities, but those disabilities did not mean he lacked a normal life with the person who knew how he moved through the world.
Then, in a matter of minutes, that relationship ended.
The Video Changed the Public Conversation
Once body-camera footage became public, reaction spread well beyond Sturgeon.
The video allowed people to examine the encounter rather than rely solely on competing descriptions afterward.
The Animal Legal Defense Fund, which later helped fund Hunter’s civil litigation, said the footage showed Teddy posed no threat.
James Crosby, a retired police lieutenant with extensive experience in law-enforcement dog encounters, also reviewed the video.
Crosby had developed law-enforcement dog-encounter training used by the National Sheriffs’ Association.
His assessment was unusually strong.
He described Teddy’s shooting as among the least justifiable dog shootings he had encountered in more than three decades of working with law enforcement.
The Question Quickly Became One of Training
Sturgeon was a small community of roughly 900 residents.
Its police department had animal-control responsibilities.
According to later court filings summarized by the Animal Legal Defense Fund, the city had provided officers with a catch pole and had an agreement with Boone County that could provide certain animal-control services, including shelter and emergency assistance.
The litigation alleged that Woodson had not been properly trained to use the catch pole and had not been told about the county arrangement.
Those allegations turned Teddy’s death into something larger than an argument over one officer’s judgment.
Hunter’s attorneys argued that the city itself had failed in how it trained, supervised, and disciplined the officer performing animal-control duties.
Hunter Went to Federal Court
Within days of Teddy’s death, Hunter took legal action.
Attorneys Daniel J. Kolde and Eric C. Crinnian filed a federal lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri.
The case sought more than $1 million and alleged a violation of Hunter’s Fourth Amendment rights.
The Animal Legal Defense Fund provided financial assistance for litigation costs.
The constitutional argument may sound unusual to people who think of the Fourth Amendment only in the context of searches.
But federal courts have recognized that killing a person’s dog can constitute a seizure of property for Fourth Amendment purposes, and that an unreasonable killing can therefore raise a constitutional claim.
The lawsuit argued that lethal force against Teddy was unnecessary.
Hunter Said His Goal Went Beyond Compensation
Money could never produce the outcome Hunter originally wanted.
That outcome was much simpler.
Teddy should have been returned home.
Instead, Hunter found himself pursuing a civil-rights case after losing him.
When the lawsuit was announced, Hunter said he hoped the case would encourage mandatory training and procedures for officers likely to encounter animals.
“I just don’t want anyone else to experience what we’re going through,” he said at the time.
That concern became one of the most persistent themes surrounding the case.
What should an officer do when confronted with a loose dog?
How much training is enough?
What nonlethal options should be available?
And when a city assigns police officers animal-control duties, what preparation should those officers receive before the first call comes in?
The Fallout Reached the City Government
Teddy’s shooting created enormous public anger.
Then-Mayor Kevin Abrahamson resigned shortly afterward.
Woodson was placed on administrative leave and later left the department.
The controversy overwhelmed the small city with calls and complaints, and city operations were affected by the intense backlash.
Eventually, Sturgeon stopped operating its own police department.
The city moved to contracts with the Boone County Sheriff’s Office for law enforcement and Boone County Animal Control for animal services.
By 2025, Sturgeon’s newer mayor, Seth Truesdell, publicly acknowledged problems in the city’s response.
“The city didn’t handle it well,” he told ABC 17 while discussing the eventual settlement.
The Case Continued Into 2025
Hunter’s lawsuit did not disappear when the public attention moved on.
Lawyers took depositions.
Evidence was reviewed.
The parties examined the city’s training, policies, internal response, and Woodson’s conduct.
In August 2025, Hunter’s side sought summary judgment.
Then, before the dispute proceeded to trial, an agreement was reached.
On November 14, 2025, the Animal Legal Defense Fund announced that Sturgeon and Woodson had agreed to a combined $500,000 settlement resolving the federal case.
It was a substantial amount for litigation involving the police shooting of a companion animal.
It was not a way to bring Teddy back.
The $500,000 Settlement Closed the Lawsuit
Under the agreement reported by ABC 17, Hunter was allocated $282,500 through the Missouri Public Entity Risk Management Fund.
The remaining $217,500 went to the law firm representing him.
Hunter also agreed not to pursue further legal action arising from the case.
The Animal Legal Defense Fund called the overall $500,000 figure one of the largest settlements of its kind involving the police shooting of a family dog.
Hunter and his attorneys said they were relieved that the litigation had ended.
But they also returned to the point that had been there from the beginning.
Nothing in the agreement could undo what happened to Teddy.
Better Dog-Encounter Training Became Part of Teddy’s Legacy
The case renewed attention on how law-enforcement agencies prepare officers for encounters with dogs.
The issue is practical rather than abstract.
Officers regularly enter yards and homes.
They serve warrants.
Respond to emergencies.
Handle loose-animal calls.
Encounter frightened pets during domestic disputes, fires, traffic collisions, and medical emergencies.
A dog may bark, run, freeze, retreat, or approach for reasons unrelated to aggression.
Disability can complicate interpretation further.
A deaf dog may not respond to shouted commands.
A blind dog may move unpredictably because he is navigating through smell, touch, memory, and air currents rather than sight.
Those behaviors need to be evaluated for what they are.
Teddy’s case became an example of what can happen when the encounter goes wrong.
Missouri Advocates Later Pushed for Specific Training Requirements
After Teddy’s death, advocates supported Missouri legislation aimed at requiring law-enforcement officers to receive dog-encounter training.
The proposal described by the Animal Legal Defense Fund called for four hours covering canine behavior, humane handling, and nonlethal methods for avoiding or defending against dog attacks.
Whatever happens with individual legislation, the underlying lesson does not require much complexity.
When public officials are expected to deal with animals, they need tools and training suited to that responsibility.
A firearm should not become the substitute for knowledge of basic canine behavior or humane capture methods.
That was the kind of change Hunter said he hoped Teddy’s case could encourage.
Teddy Was Not an Abstract Legal Issue to the Man Who Lost Him
Court cases turn experiences into numbered paragraphs.
Plaintiff.
Defendant.
Fourth Amendment.
Municipal liability.
Damages.
Settlement.
Those terms are necessary.
They allow a legal system to evaluate conduct and assign consequences.
But Teddy existed before any lawsuit did.
He was a small dog who had lived with Hunter since puppyhood.
He was born deaf or became deaf very early.
Later, he lost his vision.
He adapted.
Hunter adapted with him.
Then one Sunday, Teddy got out of the yard.
That was the mistake.
Nothing about it should have required his death.
His Disabilities Made Him Vulnerable, Not Dangerous
A deaf dog cannot hear someone approaching from behind.
A blind dog cannot visually track a person holding equipment.
Trying to move away may look awkward.
A head tilt may appear unusual.
A dog navigating by scent may change direction unexpectedly.
Those details require patience.
Teddy did not have the ability to understand that the person pursuing him with a pole was trying to capture him.
He could only respond to what he sensed.
The available evidence showed him moving away.
The federal complaint specifically alleged that he never barked, growled, or advanced aggressively toward Woodson.
That is why the video became so difficult to reconcile with the decision to use lethal force.
The Neighbor Had Done the Right Thing
That part of the story deserves to remain clear.
She saw a lost dog.
She helped him.
She gave him water.
When she could not determine where he belonged, she contacted the people she believed could assist.
Calling for help was reasonable.
Nothing she did suggested she expected Teddy to be killed.
Her later complaint made clear how strongly she disagreed with what happened after the officer arrived.
She had encountered the same dog before police did.
Her experience with him had been calm.
The tragedy came after the request for assistance.
Not before it.
Accountability Arrived, but Not the Outcome Hunter Wanted
A half-million-dollar settlement is significant.
So are changes in procedures, training discussions, lawsuits, and public scrutiny.
They may influence what happens the next time an officer encounters a frightened or disabled animal.
That possibility matters.
Yet legal accountability operates after the event.
Hunter’s original need was much smaller.
He needed Teddy returned.
No court could provide that after May 19, 2024.
No settlement could turn the encounter back into what it should have been.
A neighbor finding a little white dog.
A phone call.
Someone arriving with the tools to keep him safe.
A search for his owner.
Then Teddy going home.
That Is the Part Worth Remembering
Teddy was not running toward an officer.
He was not attacking the neighbor.
He had not become dangerous because he was deaf.
He had not become threatening because he was blind.
He was lost.
Someone recognized that.
She called for help.
Three minutes and six seconds after the officer began trying to capture him at close range, the first shot was fired.
A second followed.
The legal fight lasted far longer.
It reached federal court.
It drew national attention.
It contributed to upheaval inside a small Missouri city.
Eventually, in November 2025, it ended with a $500,000 settlement.
But Hunter’s reason for pursuing the case remained more personal than any number written into an agreement.
He wanted departments to learn from Teddy.
He wanted officers trained to recognize the difference between a frightened dog and a genuine threat.
He wanted another animal to have the chance Teddy never received.
Because Teddy had already found someone willing to help him that day.
The neighbor made the call.
The system that answered it was supposed to get a lost dog home.
Instead, Nicholas Hunter was left fighting for accountability for a dog he would never get to hold again.
























Discussion about this post